[{"text": "e", "start": 28.96, "end": 31.96}, {"text": "e", "start": 58.92, "end": 61.92}, {"text": "e", "start": 88.92, "end": 91.92}, {"text": "e", "start": 118.84, "end": 121.84}, {"text": "e", "start": 148.84, "end": 151.84}, {"text": "e", "start": 178.84, "end": 181.84}, {"text": "e", "start": 208.76, "end": 211.76}, {"text": "e", "start": 238.72, "end": 241.72}, {"text": "e", "start": 268.72, "end": 271.72}, {"text": "e", "start": 298.639, "end": 301.639}, {"text": "e", "start": 328.639, "end": 331.639}, {"text": "e", "start": 358.639, "end": 361.639}, {"text": "e", "start": 388.56, "end": 391.56}, {"text": "e", "start": 418.52, "end": 421.52}, {"text": "e", "start": 448.52, "end": 451.52}, {"text": "e e", "start": 478.44, "end": 482.479}, {"text": "we start to yes yeah broadcast now we can um Miss chair Madame chair uh you", "start": 528.6, "end": 535.48}, {"text": "can start the meeting anytime thanks", "start": 535.48, "end": 540.36}, {"text": "thank you very much and uh thank you for everyone's patience uh good afternoon my", "start": 541.6, "end": 546.88}, {"text": "name is Sarah Gore I'm the chair of the compliance audit committee I'm joined today by my fellow committee members", "start": 546.88, "end": 553.279}, {"text": "Lawrence dusza and remine faraji uh the committee administrator", "start": 553.279, "end": 558.8}, {"text": "has confirmed that we do have Quorum so I'll Now call meeting 13 of the compliance audit committee to order uh", "start": 558.8, "end": 565}, {"text": "welcome everyone today's meeting is being held with committee members City staff and parties participating both by", "start": 565, "end": 572.12}, {"text": "video conference and in person at City Hall in committee room one city hall is", "start": 572.12, "end": 577.6}, {"text": "open to the public and anyone is welcome to attend the meeting at City Hall today the public may continue to participate", "start": 577.6, "end": 584.76}, {"text": "electronically by video conference the meeting is also being live streamed online at", "start": 584.76, "end": 592.16}, {"text": "www.youtube.com Toronto City Council live ask everyone for their patience with any delays and Tech techical issues", "start": 592.839, "end": 600.8}, {"text": "I'd also ask like to ask everyone to please keep your microphones on mute unless you're speaking and members", "start": 600.8, "end": 606.92}, {"text": "please ensure that your video is turned on at all times uh I am hearing a little bit of", "start": 606.92, "end": 612.36}, {"text": "background noise and so if I would just remind everyone to please put uh their microphones on mute thank", "start": 612.36, "end": 619.68}, {"text": "you um as part of each agenda item I'll ask members to raise their hand or unmute their mic if they wish to ask", "start": 619.68, "end": 627.24}, {"text": "questions or speak and when voting members please raise your hand in front of your camera to indicate your", "start": 627.24, "end": 633.76}, {"text": "vote I'm still hearing some background noise so hopefully we can uh deal with", "start": 633.76, "end": 639.92}, {"text": "that thank you although we are in different locations and meeting remotely today the compliance AIT committee", "start": 639.92, "end": 645.88}, {"text": "acknowledges the land we are meeting on as the traditional territory of many nations including the Mrs sagas of the", "start": 645.88, "end": 653.079}, {"text": "credit annab the Chipawa the honi and the wad peoples and is now home to many", "start": 653.079, "end": 660.519}, {"text": "diverse First Nations Inu and matey peoples we also acknowledge that Toronto", "start": 660.519, "end": 665.56}, {"text": "is covered by treaty 13 with the masaga of the credit members are there any", "start": 665.56, "end": 670.92}, {"text": "Declarations of Interest under the municipal conflict of interest act if you do have an interest please raise", "start": 670.92, "end": 677.12}, {"text": "your hand and unmute your mic unmute your mic to let me know I'm not seeing any so we will", "start": 677.12, "end": 684.639}, {"text": "continue I'd like a motion to confirm the minutes of the meeting of October 7", "start": 684.639, "end": 690.68}, {"text": "I'm looking to members uh member soua thank you all", "start": 690.68, "end": 695.76}, {"text": "those in favor please raise your hand and the motion", "start": 695.76, "end": 701.519}, {"text": "carries um at this time I understand that uh we are going", "start": 701.519, "end": 706.72}, {"text": "into um uh we're going out of public session as we will have a motion and so", "start": 706.72, "end": 714.92}, {"text": "I would look to um uh look to City staff staff uh to", "start": 714.92, "end": 721.279}, {"text": "uh here is the motion thank you and the motion is that the compliance audit committee recesses public session to", "start": 721.279, "end": 727.72}, {"text": "meet and close session to deliberate in private on personal matters about an", "start": 727.72, "end": 733.639}, {"text": "identifiable individual um if I could have", "start": 733.639, "end": 739.079}, {"text": "somebody uh uh move the motion uh membera thank you all those in", "start": 739.079, "end": 745.12}, {"text": "favor all right and the motion passes and so at this time I would ask uh uh", "start": 745.12, "end": 751.6}, {"text": "City staff to temporarily close the meeting to", "start": 751.6, "end": 757.519}, {"text": "members of the public and to only provide access to members and appropriate staff for the Clos session", "start": 757.519, "end": 764.279}, {"text": "portion of the meetings and uh the live stream portion", "start": 764.279, "end": 769.48}, {"text": "will be", "start": 769.48, "end": 772.04}, {"text": "paused", "start": 778.12, "end": 781.12}, {"text": "e", "start": 808.12, "end": 811.12}, {"text": "e", "start": 838.04, "end": 841.04}, {"text": "e", "start": 868.04, "end": 871.04}, {"text": "e", "start": 898.04, "end": 901.04}, {"text": "e", "start": 927.959, "end": 930.959}, {"text": "e", "start": 957.92, "end": 960.92}, {"text": "e", "start": 987.92, "end": 990.92}, {"text": "e", "start": 1017.839, "end": 1020.839}, {"text": "e", "start": 1047.84, "end": 1050.84}, {"text": "e", "start": 1077.84, "end": 1080.84}, {"text": "e", "start": 1107.76, "end": 1110.76}, {"text": "e", "start": 1137.72, "end": 1140.72}, {"text": "e", "start": 1167.72, "end": 1170.72}, {"text": "e", "start": 1197.64, "end": 1200.64}, {"text": "e", "start": 1227.64, "end": 1230.64}, {"text": "e", "start": 1257.6, "end": 1260.6}, {"text": "e e", "start": 1287.52, "end": 1291.559}, {"text": "Madame chair the meeting has been recorded and uh uh meeting has also been", "start": 1338.84, "end": 1345.12}, {"text": "uh broadcasted you can start anytime thanks uh thank thank you very much we", "start": 1345.12, "end": 1351.919}, {"text": "have completed our closed session we are now back in public session and at this", "start": 1351.919, "end": 1358.12}, {"text": "time I would ask City staff to display a", "start": 1358.12, "end": 1363.159}, {"text": "motion and I will read the motion motion uh is that as a", "start": 1363.159, "end": 1368.96}, {"text": "preliminary matter the compliance audit committee the committee consider the request and approve the request to", "start": 1368.96, "end": 1375}, {"text": "redact personal information of the candidate Lorenzo Bard DTI the candidate contained in the", "start": 1375, "end": 1384.159}, {"text": "compliance audit report the report and the presentation slide deck the presentation from BDO Canada LLP the", "start": 1384.159, "end": 1391.52}, {"text": "auditor who conducted a review of the election campaign finances of the candidate and B the candidate's written", "start": 1391.52, "end": 1398.52}, {"text": "submission in part dated November 8th 2024 paragraph 2 the committee has a", "start": 1398.52, "end": 1405.44}, {"text": "strong interest in ensuring that hearings are open to the public public however the principle of open hearings", "start": 1405.44, "end": 1411}, {"text": "must be balanced with the competing interest of protecting privacy and security of any", "start": 1411, "end": 1416.559}, {"text": "person paragraph three in this matter to protect the candidates personal", "start": 1416.559, "end": 1421.919}, {"text": "information and in accordance with Section N9 of the statutory Powers procedures act the committee has", "start": 1421.919, "end": 1429.08}, {"text": "approved that redacting the following information from any hearing document and keeping it confidential will cause", "start": 1429.08, "end": 1435.96}, {"text": "no Prejudice to the public if I could ask the staff just to scroll up please so that uh we can see the specific", "start": 1435.96, "end": 1444.08}, {"text": "items uh can you scroll up a little bit further please thank you um so in the", "start": 1448.2, "end": 1453.72}, {"text": "report Pages four and five there's a sentence in the approach section and a sentence in the candidates", "start": 1453.72, "end": 1460.64}, {"text": "response um in the presentation slides six and seven bullet one on each of", "start": 1460.64, "end": 1467.08}, {"text": "those pages and lastly in the candidates written submission dated November 8th", "start": 1467.08, "end": 1473.039}, {"text": "2024 uh sections of that submission uh may I have a member uh approving or uh", "start": 1473.039, "end": 1481.159}, {"text": "bringing forward that motion please member fragi thank you all in favor uh and the motion passes thank", "start": 1481.159, "end": 1490.399}, {"text": "you at this time I'll now outline the procedure and format of the committee", "start": 1490.399, "end": 1495.799}, {"text": "meeting we do have one item on the agenda which is a compliance audit application um and uh the um procedure", "start": 1495.799, "end": 1504.799}, {"text": "is as follows for item EA 13.1 compliance audit report for the", "start": 1504.799, "end": 1510.159}, {"text": "city of Toronto regarding Mr Lorenzo barard denet this report was prepared by", "start": 1510.159, "end": 1516.52}, {"text": "Peter Hearn BDO Canada LP uh Mr Hearn will present the findings of the report", "start": 1516.52, "end": 1522.36}, {"text": "following this presentation the committee members will have the opportunity to ask questions of the auditor", "start": 1522.36, "end": 1529.559}, {"text": "um the uh if present the applicant for the compliance audit report and the", "start": 1529.559, "end": 1535.279}, {"text": "candidate will have the opportunity to speak to this item they'll be given sufficient time to address the", "start": 1535.279, "end": 1541.6}, {"text": "application after each speaker compliance a committee members will have an opportunity to ask questions if the", "start": 1541.6, "end": 1548}, {"text": "committee decides it needs to meet in close session to deliberate in private I'll move a motion to close the meeting", "start": 1548, "end": 1553.12}, {"text": "at which point members of the public and media will be moved into the WebEx Lobby or ask to leave the room and will be", "start": 1553.12, "end": 1560}, {"text": "readmitted once the committee resumes in public session after we've completed", "start": 1560, "end": 1565.679}, {"text": "completed our closed session discussion we will resume in public and the committee will make decision at that", "start": 1565.679, "end": 1572.2}, {"text": "time uh do either of uh the committee members have any motions to bring forward all right seeing none then we", "start": 1572.2, "end": 1579.48}, {"text": "will proceed and I would turn it over to auditor Peter herd for his presentation", "start": 1579.48, "end": 1587.52}, {"text": "uh Mr we're not hearing you or seeing your", "start": 1617.799, "end": 1622.88}, {"text": "presentation uh yes sorry I'm just waiting for the redacted version uh to be", "start": 1623, "end": 1628.76}, {"text": "oh", "start": 1628.76, "end": 1631.76}, {"text": "certainly", "start": 1647.159, "end": 1650.159}, {"text": "e e", "start": 1677.12, "end": 1681.158}, {"text": "uh okay um so this is our report on municipal election compliance audit of the campaign finances of candidate", "start": 1723.08, "end": 1729.159}, {"text": "Lorenzo barard", "start": 1729.159, "end": 1732}, {"text": "denti the compliance audit committee met on July the 19th 2023 to hear item EA", "start": 1736.72, "end": 1742.84}, {"text": "3.3 the compliance audit application of Kevin weer for a compliance audit of the election campaign finances of respondent", "start": 1742.84, "end": 1750.039}, {"text": "Lorenzo baretti the committee granted the application to conduct a compliance AIT of the election campaign finances of", "start": 1750.039, "end": 1756.039}, {"text": "Lorenzo bardetti in accordance with section 88.33%", "start": 1756.039, "end": 1761.36}, {"text": "5.1 the appointment of external Auditors by the compliance audit committee medo Canada LLP was appointed as one of the", "start": 1768.159, "end": 1774.519}, {"text": "audit firms to conduct compliance audits of election campaign finances of candidates or third party advertisers", "start": 1774.519, "end": 1780.08}, {"text": "during the 2022 to 2026 term of office B was formerly assigned to undertake a", "start": 1780.08, "end": 1786.039}, {"text": "compliance audit of the 2022 municipal election campaign finances of Lorenzo barard netti in a letter dated November", "start": 1786.039, "end": 1792.32}, {"text": "16th 2023 signed by the deputy City Clerk", "start": 1792.32, "end": 1798.559}, {"text": "the candidate fed his nomination for election as councelor for Ward 20 scarra Southwest on June the 6th 2022 in the", "start": 1798.88, "end": 1805.76}, {"text": "election to be held on October the 24th 2022 the candidate was not elected in that election Lorenzo baretti the", "start": 1805.76, "end": 1813}, {"text": "candidate did not comply with the requirements of the Municipal elections act 1996 in that he did not file a copy", "start": 1813, "end": 1819.159}, {"text": "of the financial statement ordered to report candidate form four as stated by", "start": 1819.159, "end": 1824.36}, {"text": "Kevin weiner by the required fing deadline of March 31st 2023 as set out", "start": 1824.36, "end": 1829.679}, {"text": "in section 888.259.3826", "start": 1829.679, "end": 1833.08}, {"text": "multiple attempts to contact the candidate using the contact information provided by the candidate to the city of", "start": 1858, "end": 1863.399}, {"text": "Toronto in the candidate's original nomination form as described below we sent a registered letter to the address", "start": 1863.399, "end": 1869.799}, {"text": "provided on the candidates nomination form the letter and all subsequent letters included an explanation of the", "start": 1869.799, "end": 1875.24}, {"text": "compliance audit committee's decision to Grant an audit and our request for the candidate provide the campaign financial", "start": 1875.24, "end": 1881}, {"text": "statement and all support and documentation for the 2022 municipal election the letter was undelivered and", "start": 1881, "end": 1887.24}, {"text": "subsequently returned to our offices by The Courier we sent an email on two separate", "start": 1887.24, "end": 1892.32}, {"text": "occasions to the email address provided on the candidates nomination form which included the above letter as an attachment we did not receive a response", "start": 1892.32, "end": 1899.88}, {"text": "and we called the telephone number provided on the candidates nomination form the Automated machine response", "start": 1899.88, "end": 1904.96}, {"text": "indicated that the number was unassigned having been unsuccessful in", "start": 1904.96, "end": 1910.919}, {"text": "contacting the candidate through the previous methods we looked into alternative content methods through a", "start": 1910.919, "end": 1916.559}, {"text": "review of what appeared to be a we it set up by the candidate to publicize his book boo identified an address in Ajax", "start": 1916.559, "end": 1923.32}, {"text": "however upon further research B identified that this was an address of the UPS location through a review of the", "start": 1923.32, "end": 1928.96}, {"text": "Toronto's property records voo identified a property located in scarra registered the candidate's name we sent", "start": 1928.96, "end": 1936.159}, {"text": "a letter to both of these addresses we did not receive a response to the letter sent to the Ajax location however we", "start": 1936.159, "end": 1942.48}, {"text": "received a call from the individual that received the letter to the scarber address who stated that they were the same name as the candidate but were a", "start": 1942.48, "end": 1948.44}, {"text": "different person on July 18th 2024 we engaged with", "start": 1948.44, "end": 1955.72}, {"text": "an investigative services firm to assist in locating the", "start": 1955.72, "end": 1960.6}, {"text": "candidate uh the Investigative Services also provided the candidate with the", "start": 1961, "end": 1966.72}, {"text": "auditor's appointment letter from the city collect office indicating that BDO had been signed to the candidate", "start": 1966.72, "end": 1972.279}, {"text": "compliance audit upon being contest Ed by the", "start": 1972.279, "end": 1978.399}, {"text": "invest investigative service firm the candidate called myself to discuss the letter and explain his current personal", "start": 1978.399, "end": 1986.76}, {"text": "situation the candidate stated that he was aware that the penalty for not submitting his campaign financial statement was that he would be", "start": 1986.76, "end": 1992.96}, {"text": "ineligible to be elected until after the next regular election as a result he chose not to file his financial", "start": 1992.96, "end": 1999.72}, {"text": "statement as he indicated he did not fund raise and he had no intention of running as a candidate in the city of Toronto election 2026", "start": 1999.72, "end": 2008.32}, {"text": "our overall findings the candidate did not comply with the requirement of the act in that he did not file a copy of the financial statement by the required", "start": 2009.559, "end": 2016.039}, {"text": "fil and deadline of March 31st 2023 or by the extended fil and deadline of May 1st 2023 as set out in section", "start": 2016.039, "end": 2022.399}, {"text": "888.259.3826", "start": 2022.399, "end": 2025.399}, {"text": "his campaign finances the basis for the applicant's compliance audit application was", "start": 2037.84, "end": 2043.039}, {"text": "evidence of the candidate's campaign website ww. Lorenzo barad net.com which suggests that at a minimum the candidate", "start": 2043.039, "end": 2049.398}, {"text": "would have incurred expenses to purchase the domain and host the website the candidate would have had to", "start": 2049.399, "end": 2055.158}, {"text": "receive sufficient contributions to cover the above expenses either by self-contribution individual", "start": 2055.159, "end": 2060.52}, {"text": "contributors or fundra activities as a consequence of the candidate not complying with the", "start": 2060.52, "end": 2065.599}, {"text": "requirements of Section 8 22 Clause ghi J K LM of the act it was", "start": 2065.599, "end": 2072.839}, {"text": "not possible to readily determine the extent to which if any there were any additional contributions and expenses or", "start": 2072.839, "end": 2080.2}, {"text": "determine the candidates compliance with Section 88.2 ABCD EFG n o pqr in", "start": 2080.2, "end": 2086.76}, {"text": "addition BD was unable to determine the candidates compliance with Section 88.3", "start": 2086.76, "end": 2092.8}, {"text": "4 Clause 4 in which if there was a surplus the candidate is to pay the Surplus to the clerk upon filing their", "start": 2092.8, "end": 2099.8}, {"text": "financial statement and this is uh just", "start": 2099.8, "end": 2107.04}, {"text": "screenshots of the candidates", "start": 2107.04, "end": 2111.599}, {"text": "website and that is the end of our presentation thank you very much um", "start": 2112.72, "end": 2119.32}, {"text": "compliance a committee members do you have any questions in relation to the", "start": 2119.32, "end": 2125.16}, {"text": "presentation no seeing none um we can now turn to the applicant and the", "start": 2125.16, "end": 2130.68}, {"text": "candidate uh is Mr weer", "start": 2130.68, "end": 2135.119}, {"text": "present through you no he is not okay uh in that case uh we can", "start": 2136.04, "end": 2144.28}, {"text": "proceed to uh the candidate and uh I understand that in addition to the", "start": 2144.28, "end": 2151.119}, {"text": "written submission that you provided you do have a verbal presentation and I just remind you that uh this this meeting is", "start": 2151.119, "end": 2160.96}, {"text": "public sorry I believe you're still on", "start": 2164.4, "end": 2169.16}, {"text": "mute sorry about that um I was going to add a few things um I know there was a", "start": 2171.96, "end": 2180.4}, {"text": "mention of a campaign office I never used it what happened was I have a", "start": 2180.4, "end": 2186.319}, {"text": "doctor and he has some extra space and when I went to ask on the phone", "start": 2186.319, "end": 2193.24}, {"text": "number there's a new owner of the campaign office so she allowed me to use", "start": 2193.24, "end": 2200.52}, {"text": "the office but I I only put a sign on the top I never went I only went inside look at it but I never set up an", "start": 2200.52, "end": 2207.96}, {"text": "office for example I never had a campaign manager I never had a um a campaign team in other words and I", "start": 2207.96, "end": 2216.16}, {"text": "think um well I think in the it's explained in the 10 points I mean I just", "start": 2216.16, "end": 2224}, {"text": "can't um function property the seizures I keep having all the time so um you as", "start": 2224, "end": 2231.64}, {"text": "you can see the in the in the points that I listed there um in my presentation I mean if you want me to", "start": 2231.64, "end": 2237.72}, {"text": "read into the record I will um the 10 points no that that that's not necessary", "start": 2237.72, "end": 2243.4}, {"text": "and in fact we have redacted portions of that that so that they will not be in", "start": 2243.4, "end": 2249.119}, {"text": "the public RIT record so that we can um uh preserve your privacy and", "start": 2249.119, "end": 2254.599}, {"text": "confidentiality but the the city does have it so there's no need for you to read", "start": 2254.599, "end": 2260.599}, {"text": "it okay well that was the Bas basic part of a", "start": 2260.599, "end": 2266.24}, {"text": "presentation I think I if you read the notes it's pretty straightforward okay thank you and thank", "start": 2266.24, "end": 2273.359}, {"text": "you for submitting the supplementary information uh we do appreciate that you're welcome um members of the", "start": 2273.359, "end": 2280.64}, {"text": "compliance AIT committee do you have any questions for the candidate no I", "start": 2280.64, "end": 2287.04}, {"text": "don't no okay um thank you uh and uh", "start": 2287.04, "end": 2292.079}, {"text": "thank you to the auditor for your report uh at this time I would ask for a motion", "start": 2292.079, "end": 2297.56}, {"text": "to go into Clos session and I would ask City staff to display the motion please", "start": 2297.56, "end": 2303.76}, {"text": "and it reads that the compliance audit committee recess its public session to meet and close session to deliberate in", "start": 2303.76, "end": 2309.839}, {"text": "private on item EA 13.1 compliance audit report for the city of Toronto regarding", "start": 2309.839, "end": 2316.88}, {"text": "Lorenzo uh barard danetti and to receive advice that is subject to solister", "start": 2316.88, "end": 2322.24}, {"text": "client privilege uh can I have someone move that motion", "start": 2322.24, "end": 2327.319}, {"text": "please uh member fragi thank you all in favor please raise your hand in front of", "start": 2327.319, "end": 2332.48}, {"text": "the camera and the motion has passed uh at this time I would ask the clerk to", "start": 2332.48, "end": 2338.96}, {"text": "temporarily close the meeting to members of the public and to only provide access to members and appropriate staff for the", "start": 2338.96, "end": 2346.24}, {"text": "Clos session portion of the meeting in addition the uh live stream portion uh", "start": 2346.24, "end": 2353.4}, {"text": "the Youtube live stream Port uh will be suspended until the Clos session is over", "start": 2353.4, "end": 2359.56}, {"text": "and members i' ask you remind you to arrange your surroundings so that no other person observes any part of the", "start": 2359.56, "end": 2366.56}, {"text": "closed session", "start": 2366.56, "end": 2369.359}, {"text": "discussion", "start": 2396.319, "end": 2399.319}, {"text": "e", "start": 2426.319, "end": 2429.319}, {"text": "e", "start": 2456.24, "end": 2459.24}, {"text": "e", "start": 2486.24, "end": 2489.24}, {"text": "e", "start": 2516.24, "end": 2519.24}, {"text": "e", "start": 2546.119, "end": 2549.119}, {"text": "e", "start": 2576.119, "end": 2579.119}, {"text": "e", "start": 2606.119, "end": 2609.119}, {"text": "e", "start": 2636.04, "end": 2639.04}, {"text": "e", "start": 2666.04, "end": 2669.04}, {"text": "e", "start": 2696.04, "end": 2699.04}, {"text": "e", "start": 2725.96, "end": 2728.96}, {"text": "e", "start": 2755.92, "end": 2758.92}, {"text": "e", "start": 2785.92, "end": 2788.92}, {"text": "e", "start": 2815.839, "end": 2818.839}, {"text": "e", "start": 2845.839, "end": 2848.839}, {"text": "e", "start": 2875.839, "end": 2878.839}, {"text": "e", "start": 2905.76, "end": 2908.76}, {"text": "e", "start": 2935.72, "end": 2938.72}, {"text": "e", "start": 2965.72, "end": 2968.72}, {"text": "e", "start": 2995.64, "end": 2998.64}, {"text": "e", "start": 3025.64, "end": 3028.64}, {"text": "e", "start": 3055.64, "end": 3058.64}, {"text": "e", "start": 3085.559, "end": 3088.559}, {"text": "e", "start": 3115.52, "end": 3118.52}, {"text": "e", "start": 3145.52, "end": 3148.52}, {"text": "e", "start": 3175.44, "end": 3178.44}, {"text": "e", "start": 3205.44, "end": 3208.44}, {"text": "e", "start": 3235.44, "end": 3238.44}, {"text": "e", "start": 3265.359, "end": 3268.359}, {"text": "e", "start": 3295.319, "end": 3298.319}, {"text": "e e", "start": 3325.319, "end": 3329.319}, {"text": "Madame ch you can start anytime now thanks thank you very much we have", "start": 3385.559, "end": 3391.52}, {"text": "completed our Clos session deliberations and at this time I'll ask", "start": 3391.52, "end": 3396.88}, {"text": "the clerk to please display the motion on the screen I'll only read the final", "start": 3396.88, "end": 3402.079}, {"text": "decision the full content will be available on the city of Toronto", "start": 3402.079, "end": 3407.72}, {"text": "website uh the uh compliance audit committee has decided not to commence", "start": 3407.72, "end": 3414.72}, {"text": "legal proceedings I'd like to thank both the candidate for uh his supplementary", "start": 3414.72, "end": 3420.72}, {"text": "submissions as well as the auditor for uh for the work in preparing the audit", "start": 3420.72, "end": 3426.64}, {"text": "um uh can I get a uh somebody to move the motion please uh member fagi thank", "start": 3426.64, "end": 3434.319}, {"text": "you all in favor and the motion carries thank you", "start": 3434.319, "end": 3439.599}, {"text": "very much this concludes the meeting for today and we are adjourned thank you", "start": 3439.599, "end": 3447.96}, {"text": "can I leave or yes here you're free to leave", "start": 3450.839, "end": 3457.079}]