High-Level Summary:

The city council meeting focused on various heritage permit applications, notably including discussions on a demolition permit for the Tivoli Theatre. Key participants included Graeme, the Heritage Permit Review Subcommittee Chair, and Alyssa Golden, the Cultural Heritage Program Lead, who provided insights during the meeting. They were joined by representatives from Advantis Developments and Plus VG Architects to discuss the implications for heritage conservation and urban development.

Important Topics Discussed:

1. Demolition of Tivoli Theatre (File No. 10.3, HP 2024-033): Significant debate centered around the proposed demolition of the Tivoli Theatre, emphasizing its community and historical value versus its current condition. Alyssa noted the community's interest, stating, "This requires a Council decision after further review stages," reflecting the need for careful consideration of heritage preservation against structural concerns.

2. Heritage Tree Removal (File No. 10.1): An application to remove seven unsafe trees sparked discussions balancing safety with environmental priorities. Alyssa highlighted the removal as part of a larger climate initiative, noting, "Our expert forestry colleagues deemed these trees unsafe," underscoring a delicate balance between maintaining public safety and ecological commitments.

3. Reconstruction of Wooden Steps (File No. 10.2, HP 22-436): The committee approved a retroactive heritage permit for reconstructing wooden steps at 122 McNab Street South to match existing colors and follow masonry guidelines. Alyssa emphasized compliance, stating that the work will "ensure aesthetic continuity," thereby maintaining the location's historic appeal.

4. Adaptive Reuse Proposals: Discussions included potential adaptive reuse of the Tivoli Theatre's remains, with design suggestions to incorporate modern elements while respecting heritage. The conversation balanced creativity with structural integrity and economic feasibility in preserving the site's cultural essence.

5. Community and Public Engagement: Highlighting public involvement opportunities, Alyssa mentioned chances for community members to delegate at future Heritage Committee and Council meetings, encouraging residents to voice their concerns or support and emphasizing the importance of public input in the decision-making process.

Opportunities for Public Input:

Residents are invited to participate in the upcoming Hamilton Municipal Heritage Committee meeting concerning the Tivoli Theatre's demolition application, offering a platform to express their views on the site's future.

Motions Passed, Rejected, or Deferred:

• Approval of Agenda (Amended): Passed, with additional correspondence.
• Motion for Tree Removal (File No. 10.1): Passed, allowing removal with conditions.
• Motion for Reconstruction Permit (File No. 10.2): Passed, approving retroactive step reconstruction.
• Motion on Tivoli Theatre Application: Deferred, requiring further discussions and a Council decision.

Next Steps:

The Tivoli Theatre application will be reviewed in greater depth at the forthcoming committee meetings, where public input and further evaluations are anticipated.

Councillors Present:

• Graeme (Chair)
• Alyssa Golden (Cultural Heritage Program Lead)